Mary-Michael Nonnemacher
March 26, 1983  -  April 12, 2019

Mary-Michael Nonnemacher

Mobile Memorial Gardens Funeral Home
6040 Three-Notch Road
Mobile, AL  36619
Sunday, April 14, 2019
5 - 7:00 PM
Map & Directions  Map & Directions

Mass of Christian Burial
Holy Family Catholic Church
1400 Joyce Road
Mobile, AL  36618
Monday, April 15, 2019
10:00 AM
Map & Directions  Map & Directions

Mobile Memorial Gardens
6100 Three-Notch Road
Mobile, AL  36619
Map & Directions  Map & Directions


Our sweet Mary-Michael (May-May) gained her wings on April 12, 2019 and is now our angel. May-May passed away at her home surrounded in love by her family after a courageous battle with anorexia. The love that May-May shared with all she met has taught all those she left behind to both be strong and loving.

In Mary-Michael’s last months, she bravely, with the help of her family, raised awareness for The National Eating Disorder Association in many different ways. The following link will direct you to an interview that highlights her courageous battle and has been viewed over 18 thousand times: Our prayer is that her story will continue to raise awareness and provide healing to those also suffering.

Mary-Michael was born on March 26, 1983 in Mobile, AL. She attended Holy Family Catholic School and McGill-Toolen Catholic High School. She is survived by her mother, Betty Nonnenmacher and her father Mike (Maryanne) Nonnenmacher. One of her biggest loves was her family. Mary Michael had two brothers, Lloyd (Heather) White and Mikey (Allison) Nonnenmacher. She had four sisters, Melissa (Drew) Overstreet, Amy (David) Lynn, Jenny (Chris) Reber and Theresa (James) Yarbrough. She also leaves behind 12 nieces and nephews: Justin Lynn, Rebecca Nonnenmacher, Bryce Lynn, Mary-Margaret Overstreet, Riley Reber, Grace Overstreet, Sadie Reber, Andrew Overstreet, Cole Thompson, Walt Yarbrough, and Liza Yarbrough and one great nephew, Brooks Christian all of whom she adored and loved to spoil.

We Love you High As the Sky May-May! We promise to all use the strength you have given us to spread love the way you have shown us.

The family asks that in lieu of flowers donations be made to:

The National Eating Disorder Association in honor of Mary-Michael


National Eating Disorders Association
1500 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, NY 10036

Mass of the Christian Burial will be Celebrated from Holy Family Catholic Church on Monday, April 15, 2019 at 10 am. Visitation will be Sunday evening from 5 to 7 pm at Mobile Memorial Gardens Funeral Home..
Condolences may be offered at


Sign Guestbook
  1. Patricia E Mimms
    Pensacola, FL

    Please know that I will continue to keep you and your family in my thoughts and prayers.

  2. Lindsey Nonnenmacher
    Mobile, AL

    May May I'm sorry I couldn't make it to your services, but I know you understand. You'll be greatly missed. I love you very much and I know you & Mimi are catching up and over all of us down here.

  3. Theresa and Robin Rehm-Hamilton
    Mobile, AL

    Thank you for bravely sharing your story to help others! I know you are at peace now and we are praying for your family. Love you!

  4. Jamie Wimberly
    Mobile, AL

    Betty, Please know how sorry I am for your loss. I pray that God will hold you and your family in the palms of his hands while giving you peace and understanding! With much sympathy and love! Jamie Wimberly

  5. Kimberly Gomillion Nicholas
    Mobile, AL

    Strength & courage to family & friends of Mary Michael & May she rest in peace

  6. Mike Dodson
    Mobile, AL

    My thoughts and prayers are with you and your family.

  7. Wanda Hannon
    Mobile, AL

    Love to all of you. Y’all have demonstrated much love and strength during the last several months may God be with all of you as you continue traveling this journey with Mary Michael! She is always in your hearts, 💕

  8. Kim Le
    Mobile, AL

    You are home with God. Look over your family from above as they go through this journey without you. You and your family will be in my prayers during this time of loss.

  9. Ginger Bodden
    Summerdale, AL

    God sent us an Angel to touch our heart. Thank God for this aAngel and live with her strength in your heart. Love to all the family.

  10. Ginny Sullivan Harrington

    My love and prayers are with your family. I remember when the girls were little at Holy Family. Emily and Mary-Michael spent may days together. I know she will watch over all of us.

  11. Debbie Harding
    Pensacola, FL

    I love you all and will keep you in my prayers.

  12. Helen Honey Shirey
    Mobile, AL

    My Love and prayers for the family❤️🙏❤️

  13. Glenda Sledge Rattler
    Eight Mile, AL

    My heart felt condolences and prayers to Mary Michael's (MayMay) family and friends!!
    I know how much you all love her but trust that GOD loved her best, HE sent HIS ANGLES down to take MayMay to her new HOME for some much needed REST!!!

Start Planning Now

It is never too early to start planning for yours or your loved one's funeral.